Art Journal

Some thoughts and pictures from the
Beautiful Paradise Peninsula

(otherwise known as the Wirral)



Thursday, 3 February 2011

A Tale of Two Cathedrals

My lovely girl was home last weekend so we decided to have another day as 'tourists' in our home city. 
Saturday dawned bright and sunny ... 
a perfect day to visit Liverpool's Metropolitan Cathedral  
.... so the amazing stained glass windows could be seen at their best
It has the world's largest stained glass window in the lantern tower- 
over eleven hundred square metres of incredible colour!
the vast circular interior is flooded with light from above
and the colours change as you walk around the edge from reds, to blues through yellows and greens
It's filled with incredibly modern sculptures
Outside more stained glass panels mean you can get shots like this ...
Just a five minute walk down Hope Street brings you to Liverpool's Anglican Cathedral

Inside is a vast, jaw dropping space which defies further description.
You just have to experience it for yourself

I'd never been up to the top of the bell tower before ..... two lifts and over a hundred stairs later we could see a 360 degree view of the city and beyond laid out like a map below us.
We were still there as the sun was setting over our 'paradise peninsula' on the other side of the Mersey.
Beautiful .... but freezing!
Inside the cavernous bell tower was a bit unnerving.... the size of it makes you feel insignificant.
It took us ages to get up to the top and down again as it was really busy. To our horror the coffee shop was closed when we got back to ground level and we had to go home without our treat!

I've visited both cathedrals more times than I can count ... as a convent school girl I regularly went to the Metropolitan Cathedral ... as a teacher in a Church of England school I visit the Anglican Cathedral several times a year.  I've walked around them when they're empty... and I've been to services in them both, when, sadly, it's very difficult to hear or see what's going on in either of them.

Both cathedrals are stunning in their own way ... they are so utterly different that they cannot possibly be compared. But both cathedrals, I feel, are lacking something .... once you've got over the 'awe and wonder' bit there's just no soul there ... I don't feel connected to either of them. I feel dwarfed by their sheer scale and slightly disappointed by their modernity.... both belong to the Twentieth Century.
I think we might have to wait a thousand years before they can be judged on their merits... like Durham Cathedral and York Minster.

In a way they are typical of the city they belong to ... we had to build them bigger than anyone else's because we Scousers do like to 'show off'.

And we had to have two!!!



15 comments:

  1. Great photos. The modern one looks interesting but I think I understand what you mean Cathedrals should be a thousand years old.
    Gillx

    ReplyDelete
  2. Lovely interesting post with some gorgeous pictures. Interesting what you say about them 'missing or lacking' something.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It's ages since I have been in the cathedrals but they are both stunning.We must go there again soon.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I love both but maybe the Anglican one just a tiny bit more!
    My great grandmother use to send money every week towards buying bricks for the Catholic cathedral!
    love
    Lyn
    xxx

    ReplyDelete
  5. Really enjoyed taking the tour with you through the two cathedrals. What a height from the bell tower! Agree with your sentiments about 'soul'.

    BTW I've left a little 'newspaper clipping' on my blog about the Feb photo scavenger hunt.
    http://porcelainrose-glo.blogspot.com/2011/02/heart-and-hunt.html

    ReplyDelete
  6. Striking architectire and superb photos! I might take part in the Feb photo scavenger hunt if I get around to taking the photos! x

    ReplyDelete
  7. am ashamed to admit that I went to college in Liverpool, and only went to one cathedral for graduation, and never to the other.... lovely to see inside - must have a return visit and actually find some of the culture xxx

    ReplyDelete
  8. Thanks for bringing back lovely memories of when Tony and l visited Liverpool a few years ago...amazing cathedral, your images certainly did it justicexxthanks for sharingx lynda

    ReplyDelete
  9. WOW.
    That's INCREDIBLE!
    Thanks for taking us here!!!

    ReplyDelete
  10. How very different these 2 buildings are?? and yet both very stunning in their own way. I've never been to Liverpool -but I love reading your information about the area

    ReplyDelete
  11. Ive only ever been to Liverpool once - in the Derek Hatton years and it wasnt so good, but I can see that it may have to go on the list for a visit this year. I actually quite like a modern Cathedral - I had a bit of an Epiphany once in Coventy Cathedral! xxxxx

    ReplyDelete
  12. PS How strange is this - last week, Countryfile was from South Yorkshire, and this week its from the Wirral! xxx

    ReplyDelete
  13. Both do look totally different, but I don't think I would be able to choose a favourite either as each have something different to offer. Wonderful.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Mom had a trip last year and visited both of them she took flat me with her, size wise the Anglican but the Metropolitan for the wow factor.
    Heres the link of her visit.
    http://georgethelad.blogspot.com/2010/07/flat-me-goes-to-liverpool.html
    See Yea George xxx

    ReplyDelete

LinkWithin

Related Posts with Thumbnails